Skip to content
The Sugar Question
The Sugar Question

The same scoop, four hours apart

Nothing about the ice cream changed. The hour did.

I ate the same scoop twice.

Wednesday at four in the afternoon, standing at the freezer, nothing else in me since lunch. My blood sugar climbed 48 points.

Thursday at eight in the evening, the same tub and the same bowl, but after a plate of chicken and green beans. The climb stopped at 29.

Same ice cream. Same amount. Nineteen points of difference, bought with nothing but timing.

-40%

Smaller rise from the identical bowl, eaten later

  Scoop at 4pm, alone     Same scoop after dinner
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
0m 15m 30m 45m 60m 75m 90m 120m

One person's glucose monitor, one tub eaten two ways, over two hours

This is one person's experiment, not medical advice. Everyone's body responds differently.

🍦

Alone at 4pm

+48

Point rise

-40%

Lower rise

🍽

After dinner

+29

Point rise

A scoop on an empty stomach has nothing in front of it. The sugar leaves your stomach almost immediately, because there is nothing there to hold the door.

Eat the same scoop after a dinner with protein and vegetables in it and the door is already half shut. The fiber and the protein got there first and slowed the exit down.

In other words, dessert is not one food. It is two, depending on what is already in the room.

Your mission this week

Move dessert to the end

Costs you nothing

1

Stop eating it standing up

The four o'clock scoop at the open freezer is the expensive version. That is the one to move.

2

Put it after a real plate

Protein and something green first, then the bowl. The order is doing the work, not the willpower.

Your first win

One dessert this week that follows a meal instead of replacing one.

🔬 Where this comes from: Researchers at Weill Cornell put eleven people with type 2 diabetes through the same meal in two different orders, a week apart, and published it in Diabetes Care in 2015. When vegetables and protein came before the carbohydrate, glucose ran about 29 percent lower at thirty minutes, 37 percent lower at sixty, and 17 percent lower at two hours. My 40 percent is at the top of that range and it is one person on two evenings, so treat it as the shape of the effect rather than the size of it. This may support a steadier response, not guarantee one.

Nobody had to give up dessert.
We moved it.

Rate your crash

How bad is the hour after your usual dessert?

😵 Dead. I need to lie down
😩 Rough. Sleepy and irritable
😐 Mild. A dip, nothing more
😊 Fine. Nothing at all

Tap where you are now. Try the swap for a few days, then tap again.

Keep the dessert

Jackie

Jackie

Questions, arguments, or a food you want tested? Reply to the email, or write to contact@thesugarquestion.com.

Free, every weekday

Keep the food. Lose the spike.

One short issue each weekday: a real test, a swap that works, and a trick you can use at your next meal.

Almost there. Check your inbox to confirm.

No lectures, no calorie targets, and nothing you have to give up.